Coroners' Advice on Maternal Deaths in England and Wales Routinely Ignored, Research Shows
Recent academic investigation indicates that avoidance guidance provided by coroners after maternal deaths in the UK are not being acted upon.
Key Findings from the Study
Academics from King's College London analyzed PFD reports issued by medical examiners concerning pregnant women and new mothers who died between 2013 and 2023.
The study, published in BMJ Gynecology and Obstetrics Clinical Medicine, found 29 PFDs related to maternal deaths, but revealed that approximately 65% of these suggestions were ignored.
Alarming Statistics and Patterns
66% of these deaths took place in hospitals, with over 50% of the women passing away post-delivery.
The most common reasons of death included:
- Haemorrhage
- Complications during early pregnancy
- Self-harm
Coroners' Primary Concerns
Problems highlighted by coroners most frequently featured:
- Failure to provide suitable treatment
- Absence of referral to specialists
- Insufficient medical training
Response Rates and Regulatory Requirements
NHS organisations, like other regulatory organizations, are legally required to reply to the medical examiner within 56 days.
However, the research discovered that only 38% of PFDs had published responses from the organizations they were sent to.
Global and Local Context
Based on latest figures from the World Health Organization, about 260,000 women died throughout and following pregnancy and childbirth, despite the fact that most of these instances could have been avoided.
While the vast majority of maternal deaths occur in lower and middle-income countries, the danger of maternal mortality in wealthier countries is on average ten per hundred thousand live births.
In England, the maternal mortality rate for recent years was 12.82 per 100,000 live births.
Professional Perspective
"The voices of parents and pregnant people must be given proper attention," commented the principal researcher of the research.
The academic stressed that prevention reports should be incorporated as part of the forthcoming official inquiry into NHS maternity and neonatal care to ensure that the same failures and deaths do not occur again.
Individual Tragedy Highlights Widespread Issues
One relative described their story: "Postpartum psychosis can be fatal if not handled quickly and properly."
They added: "If lessons aren't being learned then it's probable other women are slipping through the net."
Formal Reaction
A representative from the national maternity investigation said: "The aim of the independent investigation is to pinpoint the underlying problems that have caused negative results, including deaths, in maternal healthcare."
A Department of Health spokesperson characterized the inability of institutions to respond promptly to prevention reports as "unreasonable."
They confirmed: "We are implementing urgent measures to enhance security across maternity and neonatal care, including through sophisticated tracking technology and programmes to avoid neurological damage during delivery."